Rumor has it that Kristy Lee Cook put a curse on American Idol after she was booted from the show in Season 7. The curse was that only white guys who played guitar would win the show. The strange coincidence, however, is that all of the winners are in her name.
Season 7 winner = David Cook (Kristy Lee Cook)
Season 8 winner = Kris Allen (Kristy Lee Cook)
Season 9 winner = Lee DeWyze (Kristy Lee Cook)
Season 10 winner = Scotty McCreery (Kristy Lee Cook)
Okay, so I guess it would have been better and WAYYYYY spookier if some guy named Ty would have won this year… but it is STILL kind of odd.
I don’t know if Kristy actually DID put a curse on American Idol, but it is super-coincidental that all of the winners are in her name. I mean, how often does something like that happen? Ummm… hardly ever.